Firewalls and cybersecurity across San Bernardino County. Locally owned and operated, with local support. Call or text (760) 684-4139Sign inRequest service or a quote
WENO Office Solutions

Home > Church and nonprofit IT > Church scam protection

CHURCH AND PARISH SCAMS
"Father, are you there? I need a quick favor." Then comes the gift card request.

Church scams: fake pastor emails, gift cards and giving fraud

Churches run on trust, and scammers know it. They pretend to be the pastor, priest or office manager, fake the giving page, and take over volunteer accounts. These scams hit parishes of every size. Here is how they work and how to shut them down.

Protect my churchCall or text (760) 684-4139
✝ Parishes, churches, schools and ministries★ San Bernardino County and the High Desert
Buy gift cardsurgent, Father

The short answer

  • The most common church scam is a text or email that looks like it is from the pastor, asking a staff member or volunteer to buy gift cards or send money.
  • Scammers also copy the parish Facebook page or giving page to collect fake donations.
  • Old volunteer and staff accounts left active are an easy way in.
  • One rule stops most of it: no money moves on a text or email request alone. Call the person at a number you already know.
  • We secure church email, giving accounts, Wi-Fi and member data, and train staff and volunteers.
Gift cardsthe classic pastor scam
Call backstops most fraud
MFAon email and giving accounts
Removeold volunteer access

How the scams work

📱Fake pastor textA message from a new number or a look-alike email asks for a quick, secret favor.
🎁Gift card request"Buy cards for a parishioner in need and send me the numbers." The money is gone instantly.
👥Fake Facebook pageA copied parish page asks members to give through a link the church does not own.
💳Payment changesA vendor or contractor "changes banks" and asks for the next payment to go to a new account.

Warning signs

  • Urgency and secrecy: "I am in a meeting, do not call, just handle it."
  • A new phone number or an email address that is close but not right.
  • Gift cards, wire transfers, Zelle or crypto requested for church business.
  • A donation link that does not go to your church's own website or giving platform.
  • Any request to change where money is sent.

Simple steps that protect your church

  • Make the rule known: leadership announces that they will never ask for gift cards or money by text or email.
  • Call back: any money request is confirmed by phone at a known number, or in person.
  • Two people: payments and payment changes need two people to approve.
  • Lock down email: multi factor sign in for every staff account, and email security records (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) so scammers cannot send as your domain.
  • Protect giving: MFA on the giving platform and bank, and one clear giving link posted on your own website.
  • Clean up access: remove volunteers and former staff from email, shared drives, giving and social media accounts.
  • Report fake pages: report copied Facebook pages and warn members from your real page.
  • Separate Wi-Fi: keep office computers off guest and school Wi-Fi. See family friendly guest Wi-Fi.

If someone already sent money

  • Call the bank or gift card company right away. Quick action sometimes freezes the funds.
  • Keep the messages and gift card receipts.
  • Report it to the FBI at ic3.gov and to the FTC.
  • Change the passwords on any account the scammer may have used, and turn on MFA.

How WENO protects your parish

1. Email securityMFA, impersonation protection and SPF, DKIM and DMARC set up on your domain.
2. Account cleanupWe list every account and remove people who no longer serve.
3. Safe networkA WatchGuard® firewall with separate office, school and guest Wi-Fi, filtered for families.
4. Staff and volunteer trainingA short session on the scams that target churches. See phishing training.
5. Help when it happensCall us. We secure the accounts and help you report it.

Questions people ask

Why do scammers target churches?

Church staff and volunteers want to help, leaders are well known and easy to impersonate, and many churches have limited IT help. That combination makes them a frequent target.

Can the bank get gift card money back?

Rarely. Gift card money moves fast. Calling the card company immediately is the best chance.

Do small parishes need this?

Yes. Small parishes are hit just as often, and a single loss can hurt a tight budget.

Church and nonprofit ITChurch and school technology safetyPhishing trainingMicrosoft 365 securityReal estate and escrow wire fraudWatchGuard firewalls
Keep scammers out of your parish.Email, giving, Wi-Fi and volunteers, protected.
Protect my church

Sources

  1. FTC: Gift card scams
  2. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center

General information, not legal advice.